Our homemade oatmeal cream pies are out of this WORLD! A homemade pumpkin spice buttercream, sandwiched between 2 soft baked oatmeal cookies. The perfect little pie <3

These will be available ONLY to pick up on Friday 10/2 from 12-5 pm in Wading River. Address and details will be found in your confirmation email.

If this time and window is not workable for your schedule, we recommend not ordering a box as they are non-refundable :( All orders are not confirmed until secure checkout is complete, and confirmation email is received.

These oatmeal pies are available vegan and gluten free upon request! Select below if you require this version :)
They are made in a facility that does process gluten daily, so not recommended for those with severe allergies